Author Topic: DVD/Long Distance Training Questions  (Read 10476 times)

jyoung86

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 1
    • View Profile
DVD/Long Distance Training Questions
« on: December 04, 2007, 10:07:42 PM »
Guro Crafty,

After spending a short time studying the first DBMA series I have a few questions
that i haven't been too successful in finding answers for, and was
wondering if you would mind giving some advice?

 For a short while I have studied the tapes on my own, but have been
 somewhat leery of ingraining bad habits due to not having corrections and
 was considering private lessons. I live in Little Rock, Arkansas and there
 is little in the way of full time Kali Schools though there is a teacher
 that gives private lessons at a fairly good rate. Would it be a good idea
 to train on my own in the DBMA material and take private lessons for
 correctional purposes? The teacher does not train in any sort of real
 contact type training at all but i felt that he could still see mistakes
 in technique if i stuck to the curriculum from the DVDs and eventually
 tried to find training partners for the second series, etc.

 As far as training the DBMA material, namely the first series of DVDs, is
 there a certain way that you recommend training the different volumes? Do
 you recommend training only one volume until you become proficient in it
 or training the whole series in a sort of schedule/rotation? If you
 recommend training thoroughly in one volume before moving to the next, is
 there an amount of time that you would suggest one study each volume?

 I have also followed the postings on the Dog Brothers Public Forum in
 order to get an idea of training empty-hand that is compatible with
 DBMA,  in one of the threads you mentioned that it was a bad idea to train in
 boxing before learning Panantukan. I'm assuming this has to do with
 training the body unilaterally and other habits relating to heavily
 conditioning the body to use mainly clenched-fist striking? If so,would
 that also make it a bad idea to train in Muay Thai before learning the
 empty-handed FMA, or does more than enough of the same apply?

 Your time and input is very much appreciated. :-)

 Thanks,

 Justin

Tom Stillman

  • Power User
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
    • View Profile
Re: DVD/Long Distance Training Questions
« Reply #1 on: December 05, 2007, 09:50:15 AM »
Hey Justin,  I can't say I am qualified to answer your question completely but, I think it is safe to say that starting with the    (Power)  video would be your best bet.  You can train it pretty much without a partner and like Top Dog says " If you have power, you will always be a force to be reckoned with"  :-D   Good luck!      Dog Tom 
« Last Edit: December 14, 2007, 01:07:42 PM by Tom Stillman »
Live a good, honorable life. Then when you get older and think back, you'll be able to enjoy it a second time.  dalai lama

Crafty_Dog

  • Administrator
  • Power User
  • *****
  • Posts: 53343
    • View Profile
Re: DVD/Long Distance Training Questions
« Reply #2 on: December 22, 2007, 07:59:19 AM »
Woof Justin:

I just noticed that I inadvertently let your question fall off my radar screen  :oops: -- due in part to the fact that to answer it properly calls for a subtle well-written post. 

At the moment I am busy with the merriments of the season and post only to bring this TTT so as to facilitate my remembering to answer you , , , soon.

TAC,
Guro Crafty

Crafty_Dog

  • Administrator
  • Power User
  • *****
  • Posts: 53343
    • View Profile
Re: DVD/Long Distance Training Questions
« Reply #3 on: January 01, 2008, 03:35:47 PM »
Woof Justin:

You wrote:

"For a short while I have studied the tapes on my own, but have been
 somewhat leery of ingraining bad habits due to not having corrections and
 was considering private lessons. I live in Little Rock, Arkansas and there
 is little in the way of full time Kali Schools though there is a teacher
 that gives private lessons at a fairly good rate. Would it be a good idea
 to train on my own in the DBMA material and take private lessons for
 correctional purposes? The teacher does not train in any sort of real
 contact type training at all but i felt that he could still see mistakes
 in technique if i stuck to the curriculum from the DVDs and eventually
 tried to find training partners for the second series, etc."

We do our very best to have our DVDs have genuine merit for learning.  Depending on the instructor, using him to complement your work with the DVDs could be a fine idea.  OTOH if he lacks the fighter's understanding, or an understanding of what we are trying to communicate, you may find his input to be at cross purposes to what you are trying to accomplish.  In short, you will have to use your best judgement , , ,

"As far as training the DBMA material, namely the first series of DVDs, is
 there a certain way that you recommend training the different volumes? Do
 you recommend training only one volume until you become proficient in it
 or training the whole series in a sort of schedule/rotation? If you
 recommend training thoroughly in one volume before moving to the next, is
 there an amount of time that you would suggest one study each volume?"

The answer to these questions will vary according to the person asking them.  The person who tends to flit from flower to flower in Life, probably will benefit from focusing and achieving some progress before moving on.  In contrast, the person who tends to plod along past the point of diminishing returns will probably benefit from more emphasis on keeping things fresh.  These points made, there tends to be a logic underlying the order in which we put things out, but we also understand that people do things for their reasons, not ours :lol: and so seek to construct each DVD to be stand alone as well as part of a progression.  My suggestion is to read the description of each DVD and watch the promo clip for it.  We do our best to be accurate and candid as to the contents and to whom the DVD is directed.  Most of our DVDs are genuinely for the full spectrum of people out there, but some are more at one end of the spectrum or the other.  Also appreciate that it is our intention to make DVDs that continue to have value over time.  That is, you may train it for a while and then move on to other thing for a time and then COME BACK TO IT.  We continuously have people tell us that they see things the second, or third, or fourth time around that they did not appreciate the first time.

"I have also followed the postings on the Dog Brothers Public Forum in
 order to get an idea of training empty-hand that is compatible with
 DBMA,  in one of the threads you mentioned that it was a bad idea to train in
 boxing before learning Panantukan. I'm assuming this has to do with
 training the body unilaterally and other habits relating to heavily
 conditioning the body to use mainly clenched-fist striking? If so,would
 that also make it a bad idea to train in Muay Thai before learning the
 empty-handed FMA, or does more than enough of the same apply?"

I hope I didn't say that it was a "bad idea to train in boxing before learning Panantukan".  What I hope I said was that if one could start with Panantukan, that in my opinion it would be best.  My concern in all this is that people who start with boxing often have a hard time expanding to Panantukan later on.  That said, as a general rule it is a good idea to make good use of your time wherever you are-- thus if boxing is the only option, then learn boxing.   

The same point applies to Muay Thai-- however with MT you have the opportunity to work in Krabi Krabong, the military weaponry forerunner to MT, via our DVDs: specifically KK featuring Ajarn Salty Dog, the joint DVD "Cross-breeding Kali and KK" with me and Guro Lonely, and our blend of Kali and KK called "Los Triques" in the DVD of that name and in the soon to be released (estimate: 2 weeks) "The Dos Triques Formula".

"Your time and input is very much appreciated."

I hope I have answered your questions to your satisfaction, but if I have not, or if you wish to follow up with more, I will be glad to do so again.

The Adventure continues,
Guro Crafty